Better Investors vs. Bettor Investors

November 20, 2026
David C. Su, CFA

Signs of a Speculative Market

Picking stocks or putting it all on black? While dramatic, this analogy reflects how today’s market has taken on the features of a casino, driven by concentrated positions, borrowed money, and shrinking investment horizons.

“Technology has contributed to the gamification of investing.”

It has never been easier to open an app, transfer funds, and place trades with the push of a button. While we strongly support the broader participation of Americans in investing as an incredible tool for long-term wealth building, we grow concerned when market conditions tilt toward speculation. This behavior is further fueled by the explosive popularity of prediction markets, which offer a quick-payoff thrill despite high risks of loss.

Together, these trends foster an environment that is the antithesis of ownership thinking. A clear indicator of this is how the average holding period for stock positions has dipped to less than six months according to the New York Stock Exchange, about half of what it has been since the turn of the millennium.

Further amplifying these bets is the use of financial leverage. The usage of borrowed money to place trades has reached an all-time high of $1.5 trillion without a requisite increase in “equity” (i.e., actual ownership of the underlying investment). The volume of leveraged instruments like options is also peaking at a level not seen since 2021 during the pandemic-era stock craze. Investors that were once investing only the value of their own cash are now taking positions at multiples of that amount.

“Because leverage creates oversized trades, it acts as a dangerous accelerant;”

Should market sentiment shift, the urgent need to cover borrowed positions can trigger a rush for the exits, setting the stage for price drops that are far steeper and more rapid than the preceding climbs.

Crowded Trades and Skewed Odds

Dispersion, defined as the magnitude of stock-specific price moves relative to other stocks and the overall S&P 500 Index, has been hovering well above the long-term average. This points to a market sharply bifurcated into clear “winners” and “losers,” even though most companies land somewhere in between. Driven by crowding into the same familiar names, the 25 largest companies in the index (just 5% of all constituents) now account for over 50% of total index weight, far surpassing historical peaks of under 40%. This dynamic creates a self-reinforcing loop where rising prices attract attention and fresh capital, which drives prices even higher. Expectations for these bellwethers of the U.S. economy have never been higher, placing immense pressure on them to deliver and increasing the risk of severe market punishment if they fall short.

“In such an environment, the factors that should matter most to investors (valuation and underlying business fundamentals) can become an afterthought.”

At Clifford Swan, we approach the market differently. Our work begins by evaluating a company’s balance sheet strength, competitive moats, and sustainable cash flows. We calculate what the business is actually worth based on those core attributes and compare that estimate directly to today’s market price.

A sports betting analogy is illuminating.

“Fans frequently wager emotionally on popular teams like the Yankees or Lakers, which distorts the odds.”

Even though those teams may be real contenders, the poor odds make them unattractive bets at the wrong price. Financial markets operate much the same way. When prices become completely disconnected from business reality, investors are left with little upside and slim margins for mistakes.

Conversely, less celebrated businesses may offer a better balance of risk and reward. These include companies that possess durable advantages that translate to robust cash generation and growth. In fact, we believe that many of today’s overlooked businesses represent the winners of tomorrow.

Thinking Like Owners

“Our investment discipline rests on a simple tenet: we invest in companies, not stock tickers.”

While short-term trading can yield quick profits, stock prices cannot outrun underlying fundamentals forever. Eventually, business reality catches up.

In applying this approach, we caution against momentum chasing—the urge to simply follow what is currently working. While momentum investing feels comfortable in the short term, the eventual ride down is often far more dramatic than the climb up, made all the more alarming as participants frequently buy in at or near the peak.

“The math is unforgiving when it comes to large losses: a stock that drops 50% must double (rise 100%) just to break even.”

Ultimately, our role is not to place bets on the market’s next spin, but to act as prudent stewards of our clients’ capital. When the market offers a compelling opportunity to own a durable, growing business at an attractive valuation, those are the odds we will confidently play.

The above information is for educational purposes and should not be considered a recommendation or investment advice. Investing in securities can result in loss of capital. Past performance is no guarantee of future performance.